Little Sicily Pizza

Discover authentic Chicago-style pizza and classic Italian dishes at Little Sicily Pizza in Surprise, AZ. Enjoy handcrafted pies, Italian beef sandwiches, Chicago dogs, and more in a welcoming atmosphere. Call +1 623-537-5900 today!

Welcome to Little Sicily Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Little Sicily Pizza
Little Sicily Pizza
Little Sicily Pizza
Little Sicily Pizza

Located in the heart of Surprise, AZ, Little Sicily Pizza serves up authentic Chicago-style pizza that captures the essence of Italy with every slice. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff make it the perfect spot for family gatherings, a quick lunch, or a fun dinner with friends. Known for their hand-made pizzas and homemade breadsticks, they prioritize quality ingredients and traditional cooking methods. From the bustling Friday nights to quieter Tuesday afternoons, this local gem is a favorite among pizza lovers. Don’t miss out on their popular Chicago dog and mouthwatering meatball sub. Bring your appetite and enjoy a slice of Italy right here in Arizona!

Location & Contact

Address

18795 N Reems Rd, Surprise, AZ 85374, United States

Phone

+1 623-537-5900

Social Media

About

Little Sicily Pizza
Little Sicily Pizza
Little Sicily Pizza
Little Sicily Pizza

Little Sicily Pizza stands as a testament to authentic Italian fare in Surprise. This restaurant specializes in Chicago-style pizza, providing a unique take on traditional favorites. Led by a team passionate about high-quality ingredients and culinary expertise, the establishment crafts each dish with care. The menu features a variety of pizzas, including the beloved Little Sicily Pizza and veggie options that cater to every palate.

Each pizza showcases hand-tossed crusts baked to perfection—crisp yet chewy, it invites those who appreciate traditional pizza. The Italian beef sandwich and chicken parmesan are other standout offerings that keep diners coming back for more.

Guests especially rave about the antipasto salad, which bursts with fresh vegetables and flavorful meats, making it a perfect starter or a light meal. As one of Surprise’s go-to dining locales, Little Sicily Pizza enjoys consistent popularity, particularly during peak times like Friday evenings when the restaurant reaches full capacity.

Locals know to arrive early or choose off-peak times for a relaxed meal experience. Honoring Italian tradition, the restaurant also offers a selection of homemade breadsticks that perfectly complement their pizza selections, providing additional texture and flavor to every meal.

Community spirit shines here; regular customers often express their camaraderie with staff and fellow diners. Guests find joy in sharing a table and enjoying conversations over a slice or two. The restaurant embodies a genuine love for food and hospitality, making it a warm and welcoming hub for local residents.

Work Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Little Sicily Pizza offers a diverse menu that highlights the best of Italian cuisine. Signature dishes like the thin crust pizza and Italian beef sandwich draw regulars into the restaurant, while newcomers are welcomed by the fragrant aroma of freshly baked bread and simmering sauces. The space accommodates diners well, especially during peak hours when the lively chatter fills the air. The restaurant emphasizes comfort with spacious seating and a layout that encourages a community feel. Lunchtime visitors enjoy a quick meal, while dinner crowds love to linger and savor the rich flavors. Whether dining alone or sharing the experience with others, the atmosphere creates a warm and inviting dining experience.

Little Sicily Pizza

Little Sicily Pizza boasts a cozy exterior that invites diners in. Nestled on N Reems Rd, this pizza haven features bright signage that captures attention. The relaxed vibe radiates from the moment guests approach, with colorful outdoor seating options perfect for enjoying the Arizona sunshine.

Upon entering, the warmth of the ambiance envelops visitors, enhancing the dining experience. Natural light streams in through the windows, creating an inviting atmosphere. The restaurant encourages a communal spirit while being mindful of personal space, ensuring that all diners feel welcomed.

Customer Reviews

It's been years since we stopped in to Little Sicily. Not because we don't love it or had any bad experience. We just don't frequent the area as much anymore. We decided to stop in for a to go order while family is in town. We opted for a pizza, baked ziti, lasagna and antipasto salad. The meals came with a small salad which we opted out since we had the antipasto but did bring home the breadsticks that also came with the pastas. We came within an hour of closing. Everyone inside was so kind. They were friendly, talkative and even offered to help carry it all to our car. Prices are fair for the portion size. I really loved the lasagna and pizza was as good as I remember. The salad was amazing! My only negative was the breadsticks lacked a bit of flavor and were a tad dry. All in all it was pretty great. I'll have to con again soon to try a sandwich or two.

J
Janelle

Awesome little pizza spot in Surprise, was pleasantly "Surprised" with the food quality and amazing service ! Was only in town for the day and glad I made the stop to try them out! Chicago Deep Pan pizza is a must ! Thank you

S
Smartboy512

Wow! How awesome! We have been coming here for years and absolutely love the hot pizzas with awesome crust and delicious sauce! Always piping hot and fantastic! Today we decided to venture off our usual routine and had the homemade lasagna and meatballs! Came with a side salad and fresh homemade breadsticks! Lasagna is a true Italian homemade recipe that is out of this world. After having it, I swear I will never go anywhere else for lasagna. This is a beautiful peaceful place that is family owned that you will be happy to bring your friends and families to over and over! The staff is super polite and the owners are down to earth and passionate about the good things they have to offer.

T
Tim S.

This place is a hidden gem. I treat myself to lunch there every once in a while. I get their 7" pizza lunch special with sausage. The pizza is so good and is cooked to perfection. The service is always friendly and complimentary. I always feel better walking out then I did walking in. Something to be said about that.

J
Jackie E.

I am so thankful I was able to find Little Sicily restaurant. I thought for sure I would only get good pizza when I went back to Chicago. This is real Chicago style pizza! Everything thing I have had is just like the old neighborhood. The sauce is great you can get any crust you want A++ in my book and I grow in and surrounded by Italian neighborhoods.

S
Stephen G.

This place feels carefully crafted warm, genuinely friendly people, a menu that's all hits and no filler, and a calm, inviting atmosphere that makes you slow down and savor your meal instead of rushing through it. There's plenty of variety, and somehow everything just clicks, so you'll catch yourself planning what to order next while you're still finishing this round. I'm definitely coming back.

T
Tim G.